Irodov, Problem 1.91

A body of mass m is hauled from the Earth's surface by applying a force F varying with the height of ascent y as F = 2 (ay − 1) mg, where a is a positive constant. Find the work performed by this force and the increment of the body's potential energy in the gravitational field of the Earth over the first half of the ascent.

Time in the ascent 0.0 s
The answer in one line

Over the first half of the ascent the force does A = 3mg/(4a) = 14.7 J, and the potential energy rises by ΔU = mg/(2a) = 9.8 J. The whole climb is h = 1/a = 2 m.

Problem statement

Problem 1.91. A body of mass m is hauled from the Earth's surface by applying a force F varying with the height of ascent y as F = 2 (ay − 1) mg, where a is a positive constant. Find the work performed by this force and the increment of the body's potential energy in the gravitational field of the Earth over the first half of the ascent.

Interpretation. The printed force is F = 2(ay − 1)mg. Read literally, it points downward near the ground (where ay < 1) and the body could never rise. The page therefore reads it as the upward hauling force of size 2(1 − ay)mg, which is 2mg at the ground and falls to zero at y = 1/a. This reading is the one that lets the body start from rest, rise, and stop again.

We assume the body starts at rest on the ground and comes to rest at the top, and that g = 9.8 m/s² is constant over the climb.

We assume hauling means pulling the body upward with an outside force, opposite to gravity. The force acts on the body at every height during the climb, through a rope for example, and not only at the ground. Its size changes with the height y.

We assume the force points upward and has size 2(1 − ay)mg. The problem writes it as 2(ay − 1)mg. For the body to lift off from rest, the force at the ground must point up and be bigger than mg. So 2mg upward at y = 0, falling to zero at y = 1/a, is the only reading that works.

We assume m = 1 kg and a = 0.5 per metre as starting values, since the problem gives only symbols. Both are sliders. The answers are in symbols, so they hold for every value.

Symbols: y is the height above the ground, F the hauling force, h the full height of the climb, A the work of F.

The big idea in plain words

The hauling force starts at twice the weight and fades to zero as the body rises. At first it is stronger than the weight, so the body speeds up. Higher up it is weaker than the weight, so the body slows down and stops. The top is where the work done by the force exactly pays for the gain in potential energy. That fixes the height, and then each energy in the first half is a simple sum.

Interactive derivation

The solution in each frame

Only the ground frame is needed. The Earth is at rest in it, and work and potential energy are defined in it.

The solution step by step

Step 1, the total height. The speed is zero at the start and at the end, so the kinetic energy does not change. By the work-energy rule the total work of F and gravity over the climb is zero: ∫0h 2mg(1 − ay) dy − mgh = 0. The integral is 2mg(h − ah²/2) = 2mgh − amgh². So mgh(1 − ah) = 0, and h = 1/a = 2 m.

Step 2, the first half. The first half of the ascent runs from y = 0 to y = h/2 = 1 m.

Step 3, the work of F. A = ∫0h/2 2mg(1 − ay) dy = 2mg[h/2 − a(h/2)²/2]. With h = 1/a this is 2mg[1/(2a) − 1/(8a)] = 2mg · 3/(8a) = 3mg/(4a). With the numbers, A = 14.7 J.

Step 4, the potential energy. Near the ground the gravity is constant, so U = mgy. Over the first half the height rises by h/2, so ΔU = mg h/2 = mg/(2a) = 9.8 J.

Step 5, the rest. The difference A − ΔU = mg/(4a) = 4.9 J is the kinetic energy at the half-way point. The speed is greatest at y = 1/(2a), where F equals the weight. It is 3.13 m/s. This is the mid-height of the whole climb, the same as the end of the first half.

Step 6, the time. The net force is F − mg = mg(1 − 2ay), so the body moves as if on a spring about y = 1/(2a), with angular frequency √(2ag). The climb takes π/√(2ag) = 1 s.

Numerical check

A separate calculation does not use h = 1/a. It starts the body at rest and follows Newton's law, m times acceleration equal to F minus mg, in 200 000 small steps. It finds the top at 2 m after 1.0035 s, against 2 m and 1 s from the formulas. It then adds up F times the small rise over the first half of that height. It gets 14.7 J, against 14.7 J, and a potential energy rise of 9.8 J, against 9.8 J. The largest relative difference is 1.2 × 10⁻¹¹.

Five methods

1. Force method

Write the force at each height, then add F dy over the first half. This is steps 1 to 3.

2. Energy method

Work-energy over the whole climb gives h. Then A = ΔU + K at the half-way point. Here K = mg/(4a) comes from the same rule applied to the first half.

3. Graph method

F against y is a straight line from 2mg at the ground to zero at 1/a. The work over the first half is the area of a trapezoid, from 2mg down to mg. Its area is the mean force, 1.5mg, times h/2, which is 3mg/(4a). The first graph on the page shades it.

4. Calculus method

A = ∫ F dy and ΔU = ∫ mg dy over the first half. These are steps 3 and 4.

5. Check method

Units: mg/a is newtons times metres, which is joules. Limits: for small a the climb is tall and the energies large. The ratio A to ΔU is 3/2 for every a and every m.

Fastest: the graph method. Most reliable: the force method with the numerical check.

What each slider changes

ControlChanges the answer?What it changes
Mass mYesThe force, the weight and every energy. Not the height or the time
Constant aYesThe height 1/a, the time, the speed, the force and the energies
Given-answer modeSets aThe page finds a for a chosen work over the first half, and warns if it is outside 0.3 to 1 per metre
Play and time barNoPlay runs the climb in slow motion, holds 1.2 s, then repeats

Parameters

QuantitySymbolValue used
Massm1 kg
Constant in the forcea0.5 per metre
Weightmg9.8 N
Force at the ground2mg19.6 N
Height of the climbh = 1/a2 m
Time of the climb1 s
Work of F, first half3mg/(4a)14.7 J
Rise of potential energy, first halfmg/(2a)9.8 J
Work of F, whole climbmg/a19.6 J

Exam traps

  • Using the force at the ground, 2mg, for the whole half. It falls with height, so use the mean force.
  • Taking the work of F as equal to ΔU. The force also gives the body kinetic energy by the half-way point.
  • Taking the top of the climb at y = 1/(2a). That is where the speed is greatest. The top is at y = 1/a.
  • Forgetting that the body starts and ends at rest. This is what gives h = 1/a.
  • Putting the half at y = 1/a. The first half ends at y = h/2 = 1/(2a).