The potential energy of a particle in a certain field has the form U = a/r2 − b/r, where a and b are positive constants, r is the distance from the centre of the field. Find: (a) the value of r0 corresponding to the equilibrium position of the particle; examine whether this position is steady; (b) the maximum magnitude of the attraction force; draw the plots U(r) and Fr(r) (the projections of the force on the radius vector r).
(a) The equilibrium is at r₀ = 2a/b = 2 m, and it is stable. (b) The greatest size of the attraction is b³/(27a²) = 0.07407 N, reached at r = 3a/b = 3 m.
Problem statement
Problem 1.92. The potential energy of a particle in a certain field has the form U = a/r2 − b/r, where a and b are positive constants, r is the distance from the centre of the field. Find: (a) the value of r0 corresponding to the equilibrium position of the particle; examine whether this position is steady; (b) the maximum magnitude of the attraction force; draw the plots U(r) and Fr(r) (the projections of the force on the radius vector r).
Interpretation. The potential energy of a particle in a certain field has the form U = a/r² − b/r, where a and b are positive constants and r is the distance from the centre of the field. Find: (a) the value of r₀ corresponding to the equilibrium position of the particle, and examine whether this position is stable; (b) the maximum magnitude of the attraction force, and draw the plots U(r) and Fr(r), the projection of the force on the radius vector r.
Interpretation. Steady equilibrium means stable equilibrium: a small push away from r0 brings the particle back.
We assume the problem gives a and b only as symbols, so the page uses a = 2 J·m² and b = 2 J·m as starting values. Both are sliders. The answers are in symbols and hold for every value.
We assume the particle moves along a line through the centre, and that its mass is m = 1 kg. The mass only sets the time of a swing. It does not change r₀ or the force.
We assume that, to test stability, the particle is released at rest at a distance 2.6 m, which is 0.3 of r₀ away from r₀. This release point is a slider and does not change the answers.
Symbols: r is the distance from the centre, Fr the force along the radius (positive means outward), U the potential energy.
The big idea in plain words
A force is the downhill slope of the potential energy, with the sign reversed. Where the U curve is flat, the force is zero, so the particle can rest. If that flat place is the bottom of a dip, a small push makes the particle roll back, so the rest is stable. Here U has one dip, at r₀. Closer in, the a/r² term climbs steeply and pushes the particle out. Farther out, the −b/r term slowly climbs to zero, so the force pulls the particle in. The pull is greatest where the U curve is steepest on that outer side.
Is this simple harmonic motion?
Simple harmonic motion (SHM) needs a force that is exactly proportional to the distance from the equilibrium point and points back to it: F = −kx. Then the potential energy is a perfect parabola, U = ½kx². The swing is a sine wave, it is the same on both sides, and the period does not depend on how far the particle was released.
Here the potential is U = a/r² − b/r. It is not a parabola. It rises very steeply on the inside (the a/r² wall) and flattens on the outside. So the swing is lopsided: the particle goes less far inward than outward, it is fastest at r₀, and a bigger swing takes a different time from a small one.
It becomes SHM only for tiny swings. Close to r₀ every smooth well looks like a parabola, U ≈ U(r₀) + ½U″(r₀)x², with x = r − r₀. The spring constant is then k = U″(r₀) = b⁴/(8a³) and the period is 2π√(m/k). The orange ring and orange dashed curve show this ideal SHM from the same release point. Drag the release slider toward 0 and they match. Push it to +60 % and they drift apart.
The motion is a loop. With no friction the energy stays constant, so the particle turns back at the same two points and swings for ever. Play repeats the swing again and again, and the swing counter shows how many have passed.
Interpretation: this section is an extra explanation of what the equilibrium test means. It does not change the answers to (a) and (b).
The solution in each frame
Only one frame is needed. The centre of the field is at rest, and U depends only on the distance from it.
The solution step by step
Step 1, the force. The force along the radius is Fr = −dU/dr. Since U = ar−2 − br−1, dU/dr = −2ar−3 + br−2, and so Fr = 2a/r³ − b/r².
Step 2, equilibrium. At rest the force must be zero: 2a/r³ = b/r². Multiply by r³: 2a = br, so r₀ = 2a/b = 2 m.
Step 3, stability. A position of equilibrium is stable if U has a minimum there, which means d²U/dr² > 0. We have d²U/dr² = 6a/r⁴ − 2b/r³. Put r = 2a/b: 6a b⁴/(16a⁴) − 2b b³/(8a³) = b⁴/(8a³) = 0.25 J/m². This is positive, so the equilibrium is stable. The well depth is U(r₀) = −b²/(4a) = −0.5 J.
Step 4, where the pull is greatest. The size of Fr is greatest where its slope is zero: dFr/dr = −6a/r⁴ + 2b/r³ = 0. Multiply by r⁴: −6a + 2br = 0, so r = 3a/b = 3 m.
Step 5, the value. Put r = 3a/b in Fr: 2a b³/(27a³) − b b²/(9a²) = 2b³/(27a²) − 3b³/(27a²) = −b³/(27a²). The minus sign means inward, so the attraction has the size b³/(27a²) = 0.07407 N.
Step 6, the plots. U(r) falls steeply as r grows from zero, reaches its lowest point at r₀, then climbs slowly back toward zero. Fr(r) is large and positive near zero, crosses zero at r₀, dips to its lowest value at 3a/b, and then comes back to zero from below. Both are drawn on the page.
Step 7, the swing. Released at rest at 2.6 m, the particle swings between 1.63 m and 2.6 m, taking 13.6 s for one swing. This shows the stability: a push away from r₀ is answered by a force that brings it back.
A separate calculation does not use the formulas for r₀ and the greatest force. It finds the place where Fr changes sign by bisection, and gets r₀ = 2 m. It finds the strongest pull by a search over r, and gets 0.074074 N at r = 3 m. It finds the curvature of U at r₀ from differences of U, and gets 0.25 J/m². It also follows the swing with Newton's law and checks that the energy stays constant to 3.5 × 10⁻⁸. The formulas give 2 m, 0.07407 N, 3 m and 0.25 J/m². The largest relative difference is 3.0 × 10⁻⁶.
Five methods
1. Force method
Get Fr from U, set it to zero, and find its extremes. This is steps 1 to 5.
2. Energy method
The equilibrium is the minimum of U. The page shows the particle's total energy as a line on the U graph. It can only be where U is below that line, so it swings between the two crossings.
3. Graph method
On the U plot, r₀ is the bottom of the dip. On the F plot, r₀ is where the curve crosses zero from positive to negative, and the greatest attraction is the lowest point of the curve. A curve that crosses from positive to negative is the sign of a stable point.
4. Calculus method
The first slope of U gives the equilibrium, the second slope gives the stability, and the slope of F gives the greatest pull. These are steps 2 to 4.
5. Check method
Units: a/r² is joules, so a is J·m². Then b is J·m. The force 2a/r³ has units J/m, which is newtons. For the greatest pull, b³/(27a²) has units J³m³/(J²m⁴) = J/m. Limits: a larger b with the same a moves r₀ inward and makes the pull stronger.
Fastest: the calculus method. Most reliable: the graph method with the numerical check.
What each slider changes
| Control | Changes the answer? | What it changes |
|---|---|---|
| Constant a | Yes | r₀, the well depth, the greatest force and the swing |
| Constant b | Yes | r₀, the well depth, the greatest force and the swing |
| Release point | No | The swing only: where it starts and how far it goes |
| Mass m | No | The time of the swing only |
| Given-answer mode | Sets a | The page finds a for a chosen r₀, and warns if it is outside 1 to 3 J·m² |
| Play and time bar | No | Play runs one swing in slow motion, holds 1.2 s, then repeats |
Parameters
| Quantity | Symbol | Value used |
|---|---|---|
| Repulsive constant | a | 2 J·m² |
| Attractive constant | b | 2 J·m |
| Mass | m | 1 kg |
| Equilibrium distance | r₀ = 2a/b | 2 m |
| Well depth | −b²/(4a) | −0.5 J |
| Curvature at r₀ | b⁴/(8a³) | 0.25 J/m² |
| Place of the greatest pull | 3a/b | 3 m |
| Greatest pull | b³/(27a²) | 0.07407 N |
| Time of one swing | 13.6 s |
Exam traps
- Getting the sign of the force wrong. Fr = −dU/dr, so the force is 2a/r³ − b/r², positive (outward) inside r₀.
- Taking the greatest pull at r₀. The force is zero at r₀. The greatest pull is at 3a/b, which is farther out.
- Calling the equilibrium stable without checking. It needs d²U/dr² > 0, and here it is.
- Quoting the force with a minus sign when asked for the size. The question asks for the maximum magnitude, which is positive.
- Confusing the lowest point of U, at 2a/b, with the lowest point of F, at 3a/b. They are different places.