Irodov, Problem 1.95

A body of mass m is pushed with the initial velocity v0 up an inclined plane set at an angle α to the horizontal. The friction coefficient is equal to k. What distance will the body cover before it stops and what work do the friction forces perform over this distance?

Time in the climb 0.0 s
The answer in one line

(a) The body climbs s = v₀²/(2g(sin α + k cos α)) = 2.417 m before it stops. (b) Friction does the work A = −k m v₀²/(2(k + tan α)) = −12.31 J over this distance.

Problem statement

Problem 1.95. A body of mass m is pushed with the initial velocity v0 up an inclined plane set at an angle α to the horizontal. The friction coefficient is equal to k. What distance will the body cover before it stops and what work do the friction forces perform over this distance?

Interpretation. The mass is written m, and the body is pushed up the slope with speed v0 at the start.

We assume the problem gives v₀, α, k and m as symbols, so the page uses v₀ = 6 m/s, α = 30 degrees, k = 0.3 and m = 2 kg. All four are sliders.

We assume g = 9.8 m/s², and that the friction is the kinetic kind, f = kN, while the body slides up. The plane is straight and the body starts at its foot.

We assume the question asks only about the climb, up to the moment of stopping. What happens afterwards is shown in a note on the page.

Symbols: s is the distance climbed, N the normal force, f the friction force, A the work of friction.

The big idea in plain words

The body starts with kinetic energy. As it climbs, some of that energy turns into height energy, and some is taken by friction as heat. It stops when all the kinetic energy is used. So the starting energy equals the gain in height energy plus the energy lost to friction. This balance gives the distance, and the work of friction follows from it.

Interactive derivation

The solution in each frame

Only one frame is needed. The plane is at rest and the motion is along it.

The solution step by step

Step 1, the forces. Weight mg acts straight down. The plane pushes back with the normal force N = mg cos α = 0.866 times mg. Friction acts down the slope with size f = kN = k mg cos α. Gravity also pulls along the slope with mg sin α.

Step 2, the energy balance. The change in kinetic plus potential energy equals the work of friction: (0 − ½mv₀²) + mg s sin α = −k mg cos α · s. The kinetic energy falls from ½mv₀² (here 36 J) to zero. The height rises by s sin α. The work of friction is negative because the force opposes the motion.

Step 3, the distance. Collect the s terms: s(g sin α + kg cos α) = v₀²/2. So s = v₀²/(2g(sin α + k cos α)) = 2.417 m. The mass m has cancelled, so a heavier body climbs just as far.

Step 4, the work of friction. A = −k mg cos α · s. Put in s and divide top and bottom by cos α: A = −k m v₀²/(2(k + tan α)) = −12.31 J. The minus sign means the body loses energy to friction.

Step 5, the deceleration and the time. The net force down the slope is mg sin α + k mg cos α, so a = g(sin α + k cos α) = 7.446 m/s². The climb takes v₀/a = 0.806 s, and s = v₀²/(2a) agrees with step 3.

Step 6, afterwards. Here tan α = 0.577. If k is less than tan α the body slides back down. If k is at least tan α it stays at rest. For these values the body slides back down.

Numerical check

A separate calculation does not use the formula for s. It steps the motion forward in 40000 tiny time steps with the deceleration g(sin α + k cos α), and adds up the friction work step by step. It gets a distance of 2.41737 m and a friction work of -12.3098 J. The formulas give 2.417 m and -12.31 J. The energy balance of step 2 closes to -1.8 × 10⁻¹⁵ J. The largest relative difference is 6.4 × 10⁻¹³.

Five methods

1. Force method

Find the deceleration from Newton's second law along the slope, then use v² = v₀² − 2as with v = 0. This is step 5.

2. Energy method

Balance kinetic energy, height energy and the work of friction. This is steps 2 to 4.

3. Graph method

The energy graph shows the kinetic energy falling to zero while the height energy and the friction loss both rise. At the end they add up to the starting kinetic energy. The distance graph flattens as the body stops.

4. Calculus method

Write the work of friction as the sum of f ds along the path. With a constant f it gives f s.

5. Check method

Units: v₀²/g is metres, so s is a length. If k = 0, s = v₀²/(2g sin α) and the friction work is zero. If α = 0, s = v₀²/(2kg), the familiar stopping distance on a level floor.

Fastest: the energy method. Most reliable: the force method with the numerical check.

What each slider changes

ControlChanges the answer?What it changes
Start speed v₀YesDistance, time, work, drawing and graphs
Angle αYesThe picture, the deceleration, the distance and the work
Friction kYesThe distance, the work and the friction arrow
Mass mWork and energiesThe work and the energies. The distance and the time do not change
Given-answer modeSets kThe page finds k for a chosen distance, and warns outside 0.1 to 1
Play and time barNoPlay runs the climb in slow motion, holds 1.2 s, then repeats

Parameters

QuantitySymbolValue used
Start speedv₀6 m/s
Angleα30 degrees
Friction coefficientk0.3
Massm2 kg
Decelerationg(sin α + k cos α)7.446 m/s²
Distance climbeds2.417 m
Work of frictionA−12.31 J

Exam traps

  • Using mg instead of mg cos α for the normal force, so the friction comes out too large.
  • Forgetting gravity along the slope. Friction alone does not stop the body in the right distance.
  • Giving the work of friction as positive. It is negative, because friction opposes the motion.
  • Thinking the mass changes the distance. It cancels, so only the work and the energies depend on m.
  • Assuming the body stays at rest after stopping. It does so only if k is at least tan α.