A small disc A slides down with initial velocity equal to zero from the top of a smooth hill of height H having a horizontal portion (Fig. 1.30). What must be the height of the horizontal portion h to ensure the maximum distance s covered by the disc? What is it equal to?
The distance is s = 2√(h(H − h)). It is greatest when the horizontal part is at half the height of the hill, h = H/2 = 1 m, and then smax = H = 2 m.
Problem statement
Problem 1.96. A small disc A slides down with initial velocity equal to zero from the top of a smooth hill of height H having a horizontal portion (Fig. 1.30). What must be the height of the horizontal portion h to ensure the maximum distance s covered by the disc? What is it equal to?
We assume the hill height is H = 2 m, a slider, and that the answer is a general result in H. The ledge height starts at h = 0.6 m, which is 0.3 of H. It is a slider, so you can find the best value yourself.
We assume g = 9.8 m/s², no air resistance, and a smooth hill with no friction. The distance s is the horizontal distance from the foot of the ledge to the landing point, on level ground.
We assume the hill is a smooth curve with a flat top at A and a horizontal end, as in the figure. Its exact shape is drawn for the picture only. The speed at the ledge depends only on how far the disc has dropped.
Symbols: H is the height of the top above the ground, h the height of the horizontal portion, v the speed leaving it, t the time of fall, s the horizontal distance.
The big idea in plain words
Two things set how far the disc lands. A lower ledge means the disc has dropped farther and moves faster, but it has little height to fall, so it lands soon. A higher ledge gives a long fall but a slow disc. The distance is the speed times the fall time, and the best choice sits exactly halfway.
The solution in each frame
Only one frame is needed. The ground is at rest and the hill is fixed.
The solution step by step
Step 1, the speed at the ledge. The hill is smooth, so no energy is lost. Between the top and the ledge the disc drops H − h. Its kinetic energy gain equals its potential energy loss: ½mv² = mg(H − h). So v = √(2g(H − h)) = 5.238 m/s. At the end of the ledge it moves horizontally.
Step 2, the fall. Leaving the ledge, the disc has no vertical speed. It falls the height h under gravity: h = ½gt². So t = √(2h/g) = 0.3499 s.
Step 3, the distance. Horizontally nothing pushes the disc, so the speed v stays constant. Then s = vt = √(2g(H − h)) · √(2h/g) = 2√(h(H − h)) = 1.833 m. The g cancels, so s does not depend on g.
Step 4, the best ledge height. Square the result: s² = 4h(H − h) = 4Hh − 4h². Complete the square: s² = H² − (H − 2h)². A square is never negative, so s² is largest when H − 2h = 0. That gives h = H/2 = 1 m. Using the slope of s² against h, d(s²)/dh = 4H − 8h = 0, gives the same.
Step 5, the greatest distance. Put h = H/2: s² = H² − 0, so smax = H = 2 m. At that setting the speed is √(gH) = 4.427 m/s and the fall takes √(H/g) = 0.4518 s.
Step 6, a symmetry. Since s² = H² − (H − 2h)², replacing h by H − h gives the same s. On this hill, h = 0.6 m and H − h = 1.4 m land at the same place.
A separate calculation does not use the formula for s. It follows the flight in time steps of 0.00001 s, starting at the ledge speed, and finds the landing point at 1.83305 m, against 1.833 m from the formula. A search over every ledge height from 0 to H, using the same flight steps, finds the best height 1 m and the greatest distance 1.99998 m. The formulas give 1 m and 2 m. The largest relative difference is 8.8 × 10⁻⁶.
Five methods
1. Force method
Newton's second law on the curved hill is hard, since the slope keeps changing. It is not needed, because the energy method gives the speed at once. After the ledge, gravity alone acts: no horizontal acceleration and a vertical acceleration g. This is steps 2 and 3.
2. Energy method
Use mg(H − h) = ½mv². This gives the ledge speed without knowing the shape of the hill. This is step 1.
3. Graph method
The first graph shows s against h. It is a half circle shape that peaks at h = H/2. The other two graphs show why: the speed falls as h grows, while the fall time rises.
4. Calculus method
Differentiate s² = 4Hh − 4h² and set the result to zero. This is the second way in step 4.
5. Check method
Units: √(h(H − h)) is a length, so s is a length. Limits: h = 0 gives s = 0, because there is no fall. h = H gives s = 0, because the disc never gains speed.
Fastest: completing the square. Most reliable: the graph method with the numerical check.
What each slider changes
| Control | Changes the answer? | What it changes |
|---|---|---|
| Hill height H | Yes | The drawing, the speed, the distance, the best h and the greatest s |
| Ledge fraction h/H | Yes | The ledge, the speed leaving it, the fall time and the distance |
| Given-answer mode | Sets h | The page finds h for a chosen distance s. It shows the lower answer, and says no ledge reaches more than H |
| Play and time bar | No | Play runs the slide and the flight in slow motion, holds 1.2 s, then repeats |
Parameters
| Quantity | Symbol | Value used |
|---|---|---|
| Hill height | H | 2 m |
| Ledge height | h | 0.6 m |
| Speed leaving the ledge | √(2g(H − h)) | 5.238 m/s |
| Time of fall | √(2h/g) | 0.3499 s |
| Distance | s = 2√(h(H − h)) | 1.833 m |
| Best ledge height | H/2 | 1 m |
| Greatest distance | H | 2 m |
Exam traps
- Using the drop H instead of H − h for the speed. The disc has only fallen H − h when it reaches the ledge.
- Writing H + h under the root. The correct term is H − h.
- Using the height H for the fall time. The fall is only h.
- Thinking the greatest distance needs the ledge at the very bottom. At h = 0 the distance is zero.
- Forgetting the other answer. A given distance below H comes from two ledge heights, h and H − h.