Irodov, Problem 1.98

A ball of mass m is suspended by a thread of length l. With what minimum velocity has the point of suspension to be shifted in the horizontal direction for the ball to move along the circle about that point? What will be the tension of the thread at the moment it will be passing the horizontal position?

Time in the motion 0.0 s
The answer in one line

The pivot must be shifted with at least v = √(5gl) = 7 m/s for l = 1 m. When the thread is horizontal the tension is then T = 3mg = 14.7 N.

Problem statement

Problem 1.98. A ball of mass m is suspended by a thread of length l. With what minimum velocity has the point of suspension to be shifted in the horizontal direction for the ball to move along the circle about that point? What will be the tension of the thread at the moment it will be passing the horizontal position?

We assume the thread length is l = 1 m and the mass is m = 0.5 kg. Both are sliders. The answers are formulas in l and m, so these numbers only turn the symbols into metres per second and newtons.

We assume g = 9.8 m/s², a thread that cannot stretch and has no mass, no air resistance, and that the pivot is moved at a constant speed v in one quick shift, so that it moves uniformly afterwards.

We assume the pivot speed for the picture is v = 2.5 √(g l) = 7.826 m/s, a slider. The least possible value is √5 = 2.236 times √(g l).

Symbols: A is the bottom point, C the point level with the pivot, B the top. T is the tension of the thread, v the speed of the pivot.

The big idea in plain words

When the pivot moves sideways at steady speed, the ball, which is at rest in the lab, looks to be moving sideways at the same speed when seen from the pivot. A steady speed means the pivot's view is a fair one for Newton's laws. In that view the ball starts at the bottom and goes up a circle. A thread can only pull. So the ball can go all the way round only if the thread is still pulling at the top. The top is the hardest point.

Interactive derivation

The solution in each frame

Two frames matter. In the lab frame the ball is first at rest and the pivot moves, which is hard to follow. In the frame of the pivot the ball moves on a circle of radius l with speed v at the bottom. The pivot moves at constant velocity, so the second frame is inertial and the same laws hold. The steps below use it.

The solution step by step

Step 1, the top. Energy from A to B, where B is 2l higher: ½mv² = ½mvB² + mg(2l). So vB² = v² − 4gl = 22.05 (m/s)².

Step 2, the thread at the top. At B the weight and the tension both point down, towards the pivot. Newton's law for the circle gives mg + T = mvB²/l. So T = m(vB²/l − g) = m(v² − 4gl)/l − mg = m(v²/l − 5g) = 6.125 N.

Step 3, the least speed. A thread cannot push, so T must be at least zero. Then m(v²/l − 5g) ≥ 0, so v² ≥ 5gl and v(min) = √(5gl) = √(5 × 9.8 × 1) = 7 m/s.

Step 4, the horizontal position. At C the thread is horizontal, so the weight is sideways and gives no pull along the thread. Only T points to the pivot: T = mvC²/l. Energy from A to C, which is l higher: ½mv² = ½mvC² + mgl, so vC² = v² − 2gl = 41.65 (m/s)².

Step 5, the tension at C. T = m(v²/l − 2g). At the least speed v² = 5gl this becomes m(5g − 2g) = 3mg = 14.7 N. At the speed set on the page the tension at C is 20.83 N.

Numerical check

A separate calculation does not use the energy equation. It follows the ball round the circle with the pendulum equation in small time steps and finds the smallest start speed for which the thread tension never drops below zero, by repeated halving. It gets v(min) = 7 m/s, against 7 m/s from the formula. At that speed it finds the tension at C to be 14.7 N, against 3mg = 14.7 N. At the speed on the page the tension at C by steps is 20.825 N, against 20.825 N. The largest relative difference is 3.6 × 10⁻⁷.

Five methods

1. Force method

Newton's second law along the thread at the top and at C. These are steps 2 and 4.

2. Energy method

Energy conservation links the speeds at A, B and C. These are steps 1 and 4.

3. Graph method

The first graph shows the tension round the circle, T/(mg) = v²/(gl) − 2 + 3 cos(angle). It is lowest at 180 degrees, the top. The red line is zero. The third graph shows the tension at the top and at C against the start speed. The top line crosses zero at √5.

4. Calculus method

Not needed. The tension is a simple formula in the angle, and its smallest value is at the top.

5. Check method

Units: gl is (m/s)², so √(5gl) is a speed. Limit: for v just above √(2gl) the ball only reaches C. Between √(2gl) and √(5gl) the thread goes slack on the way from C to B and the ball leaves the circle. Below √(2gl) it swings like a pendulum.

Fastest: energy plus T = 0 at the top. Most reliable: the graph method with the numerical check.

What each slider changes

ControlChanges the answer?What it changes
Thread length lYesThe least speed, every real speed, the tensions and the time
Pivot speed v / √(g l)YesThe motion, the tensions and the graphs. The least value is 2.236
Mass mTensions onlyThe tensions in newtons. The least speed does not depend on m
Given-answer modeSets vThe page finds v for a chosen tension at the horizontal position
Play and time barNoPlay runs the ball slowly round, holds 1.2 s, then repeats. The time is for the picture only

Parameters

QuantitySymbolValue used
Thread lengthl1 m
Massm0.5 kg
Pivot speedv7.826 m/s
Least pivot speed√(5gl)7 m/s
Tension at C, least speed3mg14.7 N
Tension at the top Bm(v²/l − 5g)6.125 N

Exam traps

  • Working in the lab frame, where the ball starts at rest. Use the frame of the pivot.
  • Asking for the speed at the top to be zero. The condition is T = 0 at the top, and then vB² = gl, not zero.
  • Forgetting that the weight points towards the pivot at the top, so mg adds to T there.
  • Forgetting that the weight is sideways at C and does not enter the thread equation.
  • Using √(2gl) as the least speed. That only lets the ball reach the horizontal position.