Irodov, Problem 1.97

A small body A starts sliding from the height h down an inclined groove passing into a half-circle of radius h/2 (Fig. 1.31). Assuming the friction to be negligible, find the velocity of the body at the highest point of its trajectory (after breaking off the groove).

Time in the motion 0.0 s
The answer in one line

The body leaves the half circle where sin θ = 2/3, with speed v = √(gh/3). At the highest point of its flight only the horizontal part of the velocity is left, so the speed there is v sin θ = (2/3)√(gh/3) = 2.087 m/s.

Problem statement

Problem 1.97. A small body A starts sliding from the height h down an inclined groove passing into a half-circle of radius h/2 (Fig. 1.31). Assuming the friction to be negligible, find the velocity of the body at the highest point of its trajectory (after breaking off the groove).

Interpretation. A small body A starts sliding from the height h down an inclined groove passing into a half-circle of radius h/2. Assuming the friction to be negligible, find the velocity of the body at the highest point of its trajectory (after breaking off the groove).

We assume the start height is h = 3 m, a slider. The answer is a general result in h. The radius is R = h/2 = 1.5 m, as the problem says. A second slider lets you try other radii as an extension, and its starting value is the problem as set.

We assume g = 9.8 m/s², a smooth groove with no friction, no air resistance, and a body small enough to treat as a point. The bottom of the half circle touches the ground, as in the figure.

We assume the groove is a smooth curve from A to the bottom of the circle. Its shape is drawn for the picture only. The speeds depend only on the heights.

Symbols: h is the start height, R the radius of the half circle, θ the angle above the horizontal through the centre where the body leaves, N the normal force of the track, v the speed when it leaves.

The big idea in plain words

The body starts at height h, but the top of the circle is at height 2R = h, the same height. With no friction it would need to arrive there with some speed left, and it cannot. So it runs out of speed on the way up the circle, the track stops pushing on it, and it breaks off. After that only gravity acts. The horizontal part of its velocity then stays unchanged, and at the highest point of the flight it is all that is left.

Interactive derivation

The solution in each frame

Only one frame is needed. The track is at rest and the body moves on it.

The solution step by step

Step 1, the leaving point. Say the body leaves at angle θ above the horizontal line through the centre of the circle. Its height above the ground is then R + R sin θ = R(1 + sin θ), where R = h/2.

Step 2, energy. The track is smooth, so mechanical energy is conserved. From A the body has dropped h − R(1 + sin θ) = h − (h/2)(1 + sin θ) = (h/2)(1 − sin θ). So ½mv² = mg(h/2)(1 − sin θ), which gives v² = gh(1 − sin θ).

Step 3, the leaving condition. Along the radius, the force towards the centre is N + mg sin θ, since the weight has the part mg sin θ pointing towards the centre at this height. This equals mv²/R = 2mv²/h. The body leaves when the track stops pushing, N = 0. Then mg sin θ = mv²/R, so v² = gR sin θ = (gh/2) sin θ.

Step 4, solving. Equate the two results for v²: gh(1 − sin θ) = (gh/2) sin θ. Divide by gh: 1 − sin θ = (sin θ)/2, so (3/2) sin θ = 1 and sin θ = 2/3. That is θ = 41.81 degrees. Then v² = (gh/2)(2/3) = gh/3, so v = √(gh/3) = 3.13 m/s.

Step 5, the velocity at the moment of leaving. The body moves along the circle, so its velocity is along the tangent. At angle θ above the centre level the tangent leans θ from the vertical, towards the inside of the circle. The horizontal part is v sin θ = 2.087 m/s and the vertical part is v cos θ = 2.333 m/s.

Step 6, the highest point. After leaving, gravity acts only downward. The horizontal part of the velocity does not change. The body rises until its vertical speed is zero, after t = v cos θ/g = 0.238 s, having risen a further 0.278 m. At that top point the velocity is purely horizontal: v(top) = v sin θ = (2/3)√(gh/3) = 2.087 m/s.

Step 7, why it cannot go over the top. To pass the top of a circle of radius R, a body needs to start at least 5R/2 above the bottom. Here h = 2R, which is less, so it cannot.

Numerical check

A separate calculation does not use the energy equation or the formula for sin θ. It follows the body round the circle with Newton's second law in small time steps, starting at the bottom with speed √(2gh). It watches the normal force N = mv²/R + mg cos a and stops where this reaches zero. That gives sin θ = 0.666676, against 0.6667 from the formula. It then follows the free flight to the highest point and gets a speed of 2.087 m/s and a height of 2.77777 m, against 2.087 m/s and 2.78 m. The largest relative difference is 9.5 × 10⁻⁶.

Five methods

1. Force method

The leaving condition N = 0 is a force statement. Radial force = centripetal requirement. This is step 3.

2. Energy method

Conservation of energy gives v at any point of the track. This is step 2.

3. Graph method

The first graph shows the normal force falling as the body rises round the circle, and reaching zero at the leaving angle. The second graph shows the same point as the crossing of two curves: the speed squared the energy gives and the speed squared a circular path needs.

4. Calculus method

Not needed here. The leaving angle comes from solving one equation in sin θ, and the top of the flight from vy = 0.

5. Check method

Units: gh is (m/s)², so √(gh/3) is a speed. Limits: if h were 2.5R, then sin θ = 1, so the body would just reach the top and the answer for the leaving point is the top itself. A larger h lets it pass over the top.

Fastest: energy plus N = 0. Most reliable: the graph method with the numerical check.

What each slider changes

ControlChanges the answer?What it changes
Start height hYesEvery speed and height, and the drawing
Radius fraction R/hYesThe leaving angle, the speeds and the shape. At 0.50 you get the problem as set
Given-answer modeSets hThe page finds h for a chosen top speed, and warns outside 1 to 5 m
Play and time barNoPlay runs the slide, the circle and the flight up to the highest point, holds 1.2 s, then repeats

Parameters

QuantitySymbolValue used
Start heighth3 m
RadiusR1.5 m
Leaving angleθ41.81 degrees
Speed when leaving√(gh/3)3.13 m/s
Speed at the highest point(2/3)√(gh/3)2.087 m/s
Height of the highest point2.78 m

Exam traps

  • Saying the speed at the highest point is zero. The body still moves sideways there, with speed v sin θ.
  • Using the speed when it leaves, √(gh/3), as the answer. That is the speed at the leaving point, not at the top of the flight.
  • Measuring θ from the vertical or from the bottom of the circle. Here it is measured above the horizontal through the centre.
  • Writing the leaving condition as v = 0. It is N = 0, and v is not zero then.
  • Forgetting the height of the leaving point is R(1 + sin θ), not R sin θ.